Confidence & Communication

Use These Follow-Up Strategies to Catch When Someone’s Lying

A well-timed follow-up forces any story to prove itself on the spot. Borrowing tactics from detective interrogations and poker tables, these strategies reveal the truth without starting an argument.

Life Skills

Ask the same question twice, and watch what happens between the two answers. That's where most people give themselves away. 

A candidate who says they led the migration to a new system at their last job should describe the same problem and solution in detail during the second interview. A first date who mentions a recent trip, a new car, or a bonus should hold up the same way when a casual follow-up comes later in the night.

Those padding the truth may add details that weren't there before or back off parts of their original story that don’t hold up. That's the utility of a good follow-up: it works like an invitation when you’re dealing with incomplete information. 

  1. Act Like You Know More Than You Do

At the poker table there’s a word for the flicker that gives someone away: a tell. The real tells are small: a half-second pause before an answer, shifting details, or an ever-expanding explanation. It’s rarely the big stuff like a visible wince or cracking voice.

Researcher Cody Porter built a technique around making a tell show up on command. It's called asymmetric information management, and the mechanics are almost sneakily simple: mention, in passing, that you've already looked into the details — "I checked with your last manager on the timeline," or "I pulled the invoice before we talked." Someone telling the truth has nothing to lose by adding more, so they tend to give it. A person managing a version of events has everything to lose if one detail turns out wrong, so they tend to hold back instead, keeping their account vague enough that nothing in it can be discredited. 

So do your due diligence: review the invoice, memorize the timeline, and whoever else was in the room. Mention it once you have, then let it sit. That's the strategic move — naming a fact and letting the other person decide what to do with it.

  1. Ask the Right Question in the Right Way

Detective Joshua Mason built his method on one small swap: trade "why" for "what." As he tells Fast Company, questions like "What happened next?" or "What did you do when that happened?" push someone to produce a new piece of the story on the spot, something they haven't rehearsed. A prepared reason is easy to repeat word for word, but details fabricated under pressure rarely survive a second telling.

Say a vendor's quote comes back $3,000 higher than the one from three months ago, pinned on rising material costs. Ask what's driving the number: "What exactly changed in your costs since the last quote?" A legitimate increase breaks down the same way every time. A padded one starts moving pieces around on the second pass: materials, then labor, perhaps a cost that wasn’t mentioned the first time.

The best version sounds like idle curiosity, which is exactly why nobody sees it coming. None of this needs to use the tone of an interrogation.

  1. Let the Silence Do the Work

Asking the question is the easy part. What happens in the ten seconds after is the real tell. Instead of rushing to fill a pause, offer a way out, or apologize for pushing, let them carry the weight of their words. 

Notice if they offer a correction to their story or add a detail without being prompted. These are the moments a story confirms itself or starts coming apart in real time. None of those reactions prove anything in isolation, but strung together over a few questions, they add up to a sharper sense of what's true. Let it happen in the open. The urge to jump in and smooth it over is worth resisting when you’re after the truth. 

Back to You 

Deception collapses under its own weight — it just needs a little room to fall apart. Feign a bit of context you don’t have, trade ‘why’ for ‘what,’ and let silence handle whatever’s left over.

The next time a claim or story feels slightly off, step back and let the truth introduce itself.

STRATEGIC PLAY

Play Your First Game!

Learn the ropes in 5 minutes with our guided walk-through.

Try Your First Game

Learn at Your Own Pace

Sign Up for Live Group Lessons

Browse Lessons

You might also like

‘Conscious Unbossing’: How to Decline the Ladder and Keep the Influence

Read Story

Taking a Pay Cut for Equity? How to Make Sure the Pot Odds Actually Add Up

Read Story

Why Slowing Down Is the Smartest Career Move You Can Make Right Now

Read Story